Hidden Anguish
First responders play a vital and commendable role in society as they display exceptional bravery to save the lives of others, often at the risk of their own. Many first responders encounter unimaginable tragedy and horror on a daily basis, and then are expected to go home and attend to their loved ones. However, separating work from personal life may not be so easy for these individuals as the impact that traumatic events can have on one’s mental health is often left unacknowledged. Frequent exposure to death and tragedy undoubtedly affects one’s psychological state of well-being, including post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), substance abuse, depression and especially suicidal ideations. However, along with the societal expectation of first responders to be brave and strong, comes the suppression of such mental health problems and lack of proper psychiatric treatment.[1]
Risk factors & Causes
In comparison to the general population, first responders such as law enforcement officers (LEO), emergency medical technicians (EMT), and firefighters are at a greater risk of suicide ideation and suicide. Stanley et. al. (2016) conducted a systematic review of 63 quantitative studies examining the suicidal thoughts, behaviors, and fatalities of first responders, and found them to be at a significantly higher risk than general population samples.[2] Bond & Anestis (2021) conducted a study which showed that 23-25% of LEOs and 46.8% of firefighters experience suicidal ideations, and 10.4% of EMTs report severe lifetime suicidal ideation.[3] Frequent and severe traumatic experiences also lead to a higher risk of PTSD. Approximately 32% of LEOs, 22% of EMTs and 32% of firefighters experience PTSD. In comparison to the general civilian population, out of whom only 7-12% experience PTSD, these rates are concerningly high. There are also various risk factors amongst first responders that can contribute to their increased risk of developing PTSD, including:[4]
Family history of psychiatric disorders
Childhood trauma (abuse/adversity)
Intelligence level
Education
Early conduct problems
Proper sleep hygiene (due to long and demanding shift schedules) also plays a role in the increased rates of disorders such as PTSD, depression, and anxiety. A longitudinal study conducted by Feldman et al. (2021) included 135 emergency medical service providers and recorded changes in symptoms of various psychological disorders over the course of 3 months. Their findings revealed that the increase in symptoms of PTSD, depression, and anxiety were all correlated with a poor sleep pattern and lower social support.[5] Erratic sleep patterns are especially problematic given that they compromise inflammatory and physiological stress responses.[6]
Acute stress disorder (ASD) is another common psychiatric disorder among first responders who experience frequent and high-impact stressors. A few pertinent symptoms of this disorder include:[7]
Hyperarousal
Negative mood
Anger/irritability
Avoidance
Numbing
Nightmares
Intrusive thoughts
ASD is developed once an acute stress response leads to more serious impairments after exposure to a traumatic stress with documented biological or psychological sequelae. Within 3 days of the traumatic event, multiple symptoms within five diagnostic categories will appear. ASD is signified by persistent symptoms well beyond the time frame of an acute stress reaction, which is more common and normal for anyone who experiences a traumatic event. While first responders who are acutely impacted by a trauma may develop ASD, developing ASD puts them at a greater risk for subsequently developing PTSD.[8]
The Three-Step Theory
Not only do first responders experience greater rates of suicidal ideations, but they are also more likely to actually perform suicidal attempts.[9] Ideation-to-action is outlined by the Three-Step Theory (3ST), which states that there are three subcategories of capability that can shift an individual from suicidal thoughts to actual suicidal actions. These subcategories include:[10]
Practical - Broader knowledge of lethal weapons/drugs, and potentially even better access to them. The means of suicidal means are more readily obtainable.
Dispositional - Innate tolerance to death and pain.
Acquired - Learned desensitization and tolerance to death and pain. Having encountered numerous tragic events has built a sense of fearlessness in many first responders.
Suffering in Silence
Since a large majority of first responder suicides go unreported by mainstream media, there is an ongoing lack of knowledge/awareness of the general public to the degree that it occurs. In addition, barriers exist that prevent first responders from accessing the proper psychiatric care they need when experiencing depression or suicidal ideations. Such barriers include shame and stigma surrounding mental health issues within their professions, as the concept of bravery and courage is heavily instilled upon them during training and work. Moreover, first responders and their families often fail to have open discussions about mental health, which unfortunately fuels the lack of awareness on the issue of first responder suicide.[11]
Even when a first responder recognizes they are in crisis, several factors often prevent them from seeking adequate help: lack of knowledge on where/how to seek help, fear of confidentiality breach, belief that they cannot show weakness, lack of access and availability to therapy, family burden, pride and denial.[12] Destigmatizing mental health issues and spreading awareness is the first crucial step to ensuring that first responders are able to comfortably and willingly ask for help.[13] First responders should also be informed about mental health disorders and how to facilitate help-seeking.[14]
First responders are often expected to prevent their traumatic experiences from interfering with their professional and personal lives. The culture of first responders may prevent them from seeking actual mental health interventions, due to stigma and self-image. However, doing so often leads to unhealthy coping mechanisms such as substance abuse and high-risk behavior as an outlet for their stressors. Some also practice avoidance, leading to absenteeism in work and home, causing tension with their personal relationships. Conflict may even arise between colleagues, as high-stress environments and internal stressors combine together to create overall tension in the workplace. Therefore, psychoeducation to reduce stigma and subcultural barriers could help encourage first responders to seek treatment. This would eventually remediate their own psychological health and mend other impacted professional and personal relationships in their lives.[15]
Building Resilience
High resilience has been shown to be associated with lower symptomology of PTSD, depression, and alcohol abuse in active first responders. Therefore, resilience screening can help to protect the long-term mental health of first responders. High resilience indicates the ability to better tolerate problems, illness, failure, pressure, and feelings of pain.
These adaptive qualities of resilience can be developed in first responders via targeted interventions, including cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and mindfulness training programs. These two methods have been proven effective in increasing adaptive resilience amongst health professionals, factory workers, civil servants, and even breast-cancer patients. Employing resilience screening as a first responder begins work, one can identify which workers can most benefit from these targeted interventions to increase resilience, thus decreasing their chances of developing debilitating psychological disorders.[16]
Thompson and Drew (2020) developed a 21-day program to enhance first responder resilience and tested the program with promising results. Every day over the course of 21 days, participants received a keyword which encouraged them to follow certain practices for the day, such as grit, calm, empathy, and gratitude. They also did 5 minutes of controlled breathing exercises, short readings on the keywords, reflections for the day, and an evening gratitude practice. Gratitude was incorporated into the program to increase sleep quality, life satisfaction, and decrease risk of depressive symptoms. In total, the practice work took only 15 minutes a day, accounting for the busy schedules of typical first responders. The participants responded to the 21 day course well, and a majority indicated that they would continue to use the practices they learned during the course of the program.[17]
Programs such as this one, and other resilience programs, would be beneficial for all first responders to incorporate into their lifestyles to increase resilience against developing mental health issues, promote the necessity of managing one’s mental health and reduce stigma in those suffering with PTSD, depression, anxiety and other work-related mental health disorders.
If one has been suffering from any mental health disorder due to traumatic stress, such as PTSD or ASD, or is experiencing feelings of heightened anxiety or suicidal ideations, it is crucial to contact a licensed mental health professional (e.g., a psychotherapist, psychologist or psychiatrist) for guidance and support.
Contributed by: Ananya Udyaver
Editor: Jennifer (Ghahari) Smith, Ph.D.
References
1 Heyman, M., Dill, J., & Douglas, R. (2018, April). The ruderman white paper on mental health and suicide of first ... https://firefightermentalhealth.org/system/files/First%20Responder%20White%20Paper_Final.pdf
2 Stanley, I., Hom, M., & Joiner, T. (2015, December 12). A systematic review of suicidal thoughts and behaviors among police officers, firefighters, emts, and Paramedics. Clinical Psychology Review. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0272735815300684?via%3Dihub
3 Bond, A., & Anestis, M. (2021, October 26). Understanding capability and suicidal ideation among first responders. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13811118.2021.1993397
4 Lewis-Schroeder, N. F., Kieran, K., Murphy, B. L., Wolff, J. D., Robinson, M. A., & Kaufman, M. L. (2018). Conceptualization, Assessment, and Treatment of Traumatic Stress in First Responders: A Review of Critical Issues. Harvard review of psychiatry, 26(4), 216–227. https://doi.org/10.1097/HRP.0000000000000176
5 Feldman, T. R., Carlson, C. L., Rice, L. K., Kruse, M. I., Beevers, C. G., Telch, M. J., & Josephs, R. A. (2021). Factors predicting the development of psychopathology among first responders: A prospective, longitudinal study. Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy, 13(1), 75–83. https://doi.org/10.1037/tra0000957
6 Lewis-Schroeder, N. F., Kieran, K., Murphy, B. L., Wolff, J. D., Robinson, M. A., & Kaufman, M. L. (2018).
7 Ibid.
8 Ibid.
9 Bond, A., & Anestis, M. (2021, October 26).
10 Heyman, M., Dill, J., & Douglas, R. (2018, April).
11 Stanley, I., Hom, M., & Joiner, T. (2015, December 12).
12 Jones S, Agud K, McSweeney J. (2020) Barriers and Facilitators to Seeking Mental Health Care Among First Responders: “Removing the Darkness.” Journal of the American Psychiatric Nurses Association. 26(1):43-54. doi:10.1177/1078390319871997
13 Heyman, M., Dill, J., & Douglas, R. (2018, April).
14 Jones S, Agud K, McSweeney J. (2020)
15 Lewis-Schroeder, N. F., Kieran, K., Murphy, B. L., Wolff, J. D., Robinson, M. A., & Kaufman, M. L. (2018).
16 Joyce, S., Tan, L., Shand, F., Bryant, R., & Harvey, S. (2019). Can resilience be measured and used to predict mental... : Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine. LWW. https://journals.lww.com/joem/abstract/2019/04000/can_resilience_be_measured_and_used_to_predict.4.aspx
17 Thompson, J., & Drew, J. M. (2020, July 27). Warr;OR21: A 21-day program to enhance first responder resilience and mental health. Frontiers. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.02078/full